Overview
Marissa Irvine has one simple task: collect her young son Milo after his first playdate at a classmate's house in Chicago. When she knocks on the door of 14 Arthur Avenue, a stranger answers. No Milo. No explanation. No one who should be there at all. What follows peels back the surface of a quiet neighborhood to reveal the kind of secrets that ordinary-looking people work very hard to keep buried.
Top Cast
What TV shows are similar to All Her Fault?
If you are looking for the best TV shows like All Her Fault (2025) · 8.0 , these three titles are the best similar matches sharing its vibe:
All Her Fault Episode Ratings
Visual map of all episodes based on user scores. Red indicates lower ratings, green indicates highly-rated episodes.
Analyzing...
All Her Fault
Best TV Shows Like All Her Fault
If you are searching for TV shows like "All Her Fault", our recommendation engine has compiled the best alternatives. Discover highly rated and entertaining titles that perfectly capture the Crime and Mystery vibe.
Nine Bodies in a Mexican Morgue (2025)
A small charter plane bound for the United States goes down somewhere in the Mexican jungle, stranding nine strangers with no clear...
Defending Jacob (2020)
When a teenager in a quiet Massachusetts suburb becomes the prime suspect in a classmate's murder, his father, an assistant district attorney,...
Lupin (2021)
Assane Diop grew up reading about Arsène Lupin, the legendary gentleman thief, and those stories became his blueprint. Now an adult with...
Fool Me Once (2024)
Maya thought she was grieving a husband. Then she spotted him on a hidden nanny cam, very much alive, days after his...
Imperfect Women (2026)
Three women have kept each other's secrets for decades. When one of them turns up dead, the investigation doesn't just pursue a...
Detective Hole (2026)
Oslo is shaken by a string of killings that share an unsettling, deliberate logic, the kind that points toward something organized and...
Under Salt Marsh (2026)
Wedged between unforgiving mountains and a sea that keeps stealing ground, the Welsh town of Morfa Halen holds its breath as a...
I Will Find You (2026)
Convicted of killing his own son and sentenced to life in prison, a father has resigned himself to a future behind bars....
Sherlock (2010)
Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock Holmes is bored, brilliant, and barely tolerant of ordinary human beings, which makes him perfectly suited for the darkest...
Dexter (2006)
By day, Dexter Morgan reads blood. Literally. As a forensic analyst for the Miami Metro Police, he is unusually gifted at reconstructing...
Mare of Easttown (2021)
In the tight-knit, working-class suburb of Easttown, Pennsylvania, detective Mare Sheehan is the kind of cop who knows everyone's business and carries...
You (2018)
Joe Goldberg is the kind of man who seems perfect on paper: well-read, attentive, quietly devoted. He is also someone who will...
Most similar TV shows to All Her Fault
Looking for more TV shows like All Her Fault (2025)? If you loved the critically acclaimed and masterpiece experience of this classic, you are in the right place. Fans of All Her Fault will especially appreciate our curated list of similar series within the Crime and Mystery genre.
Here are the top TV shows similar to All Her Fault to add to your watchlist right now: Nine Bodies in a Mexican Morgue, Defending Jacob, Lupin, Fool Me Once, Imperfect Women. Explore these highly rated recommendations to find your next favorite!
All Her Fault FAQ
What are the best TV shows like All Her Fault?
If you enjoyed All Her Fault, you should definitely add Nine Bodies in a Mexican Morgue, Defending Jacob, and Lupin to your watchlist. These TV shows share similar highly rated and entertaining themes, making them a perfect match for fans of the Crime and Mystery genre.
What is the vibe and genre of All Her Fault?
All Her Fault is primarily a Crime and Mystery series. It is known for its critically acclaimed and masterpiece undertones. With a user rating of 8.0, it delivers a highly immersive cinematic experience.
What to watch next after All Her Fault?
Once you have finished All Her Fault, you might be craving more stories with immersive and popular elements. Our recommendation algorithm highly suggests checking out Fool Me Once or Imperfect Women as your next watch. Both titles capture that same unique vibe!